Replacement Windows : Vinyl, Wood, or Composite?

So, when replacing the windows on your house, what exactly is the best route to go down?

Vinyl windows, composite windows, or aluminum replacement windows?

I was sifting through Yahoo Answers today and found this very same question. Here is the answer as provided by BearDown (I’m guessing BearDown is a windows expert given the name, as in “Bear Down the Hatches”) :

Okay, theres a difference between replacement windows (vinyl) and replacing old windows with new windows. Since you mention wood and aluminum as options, I’m assuming you mean replacing the old with new and not actual replacement windows, which amounts to mounting a vinyl sash assembly into the old window frame.

So with that in mind and respect to everyone else who prefer vinyl, in my opinion vinyl is nothing more than a low budget option. Aluminum clad windows are the best option when you factor in looks, functionality, performance, durability and maintainence versus cost. Vinyl, like all polymer based products, degrades when exposed to elements such as sunlight, rain, wind, heat and cold, leaving the vinyl brittle and susceptible to cracking. Not to mention, vinyl windows look really cheap and mechanically, do not function as well as wood or aluminum. If you are replacing old window units with new window units, aluminum clad is the best option.

If you do indeed mean actual replacement windows, I’ve only seen them in vinyl, no wood or aluminum options, just vinyl. But, I’ve been retired a couple of years, and these may be new options that I’m not aware of. If these ARE new options, I’d probably still be inclined to recommend the aluminum for the same reasons stated above.

One comment

  1. Most of the vinyl windows on the market are actually vinyl that is mixed with plastic. The plastic breaks down when exposed to the UV rays. Good vinyl windows (UPVC) are made with pure virgin vinyl and do not include any plastic. Vinyl windows have been around since the 1960’s and some of the original ones are still in use.

    If you buy cheap vinyl windows you can expect failure within 3-5 years. No window is more expensive than a cheap vinyl window (you have to replace them several times).

    I have been working on an article for my blog that should get publish within a few days on this exact topic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>